Download Verdun: The Longest Battle of the Great War, by Paul Jankowski
This letter might not influence you to be smarter, however the book Verdun: The Longest Battle Of The Great War, By Paul Jankowski that we offer will certainly stimulate you to be smarter. Yeah, at least you'll know more than others that do not. This is exactly what called as the top quality life improvisation. Why must this Verdun: The Longest Battle Of The Great War, By Paul Jankowski It's considering that this is your preferred style to review. If you like this Verdun: The Longest Battle Of The Great War, By Paul Jankowski motif around, why don't you check out the book Verdun: The Longest Battle Of The Great War, By Paul Jankowski to improve your discussion?
Verdun: The Longest Battle of the Great War, by Paul Jankowski
Download Verdun: The Longest Battle of the Great War, by Paul Jankowski
Invest your time also for simply couple of mins to review an e-book Verdun: The Longest Battle Of The Great War, By Paul Jankowski Checking out a publication will certainly never lower and also waste your time to be pointless. Reading, for some folks end up being a need that is to do everyday such as hanging out for consuming. Now, exactly what about you? Do you like to review a publication? Now, we will certainly show you a brand-new e-book entitled Verdun: The Longest Battle Of The Great War, By Paul Jankowski that can be a brand-new method to explore the knowledge. When reviewing this e-book, you could obtain something to always remember in every reading time, even detailed.
But below, we will reveal you extraordinary point to be able constantly review guide Verdun: The Longest Battle Of The Great War, By Paul Jankowski wherever and also whenever you happen and time. Guide Verdun: The Longest Battle Of The Great War, By Paul Jankowski by only could aid you to recognize having the publication to read every single time. It won't obligate you to always bring the thick book wherever you go. You can simply maintain them on the kitchen appliance or on soft documents in your computer system to consistently review the space at that time.
Yeah, hanging around to read the publication Verdun: The Longest Battle Of The Great War, By Paul Jankowski by on-line could additionally give you positive session. It will certainly reduce to communicate in whatever condition. In this manner can be much more fascinating to do as well as easier to review. Now, to obtain this Verdun: The Longest Battle Of The Great War, By Paul Jankowski, you could download and install in the web link that we supply. It will certainly assist you to obtain simple means to download and install the e-book Verdun: The Longest Battle Of The Great War, By Paul Jankowski.
The e-books Verdun: The Longest Battle Of The Great War, By Paul Jankowski, from easy to complicated one will certainly be a quite helpful operates that you could take to change your life. It will certainly not give you unfavorable declaration unless you do not obtain the significance. This is certainly to do in reviewing a book to get over the definition. Generally, this book qualified Verdun: The Longest Battle Of The Great War, By Paul Jankowski is checked out due to the fact that you truly like this sort of e-book. So, you could get simpler to understand the impression and definition. Once again to always remember is by reading this e-book Verdun: The Longest Battle Of The Great War, By Paul Jankowski, you could fulfil hat your interest begin by finishing this reading book.
At seven o'clock in the morning on February 21, 1916, the ground in northern France began to shake. For the next ten hours, twelve hundred German guns showered shells on a salient in French lines. The massive weight of explosives collapsed dugouts, obliterated trenches, severed communication wires, and drove men mad. As the barrage lifted, German troops moved forward, darting from shell crater to shell crater. The battle of Verdun had begun.
In Verdun, historian Paul Jankowski provides the definitive account of the iconic battle of World War I. A leading expert on the French past, Jankowski combines the best of traditional military history-its emphasis on leaders, plans, technology, and the contingency of combat-with the newer social and cultural approach, stressing the soldier's experience, the institutional structures of the military, and the impact of war on national memory. Unusually, this book draws on deep research in French and German archives; this mastery of sources in both languages gives Verdun unprecedented authority and scope. In many ways, Jankowski writes, the battle represents a conundrum. It has an almost unique status among the battles of the Great War; and yet, he argues, it was not decisive, sparked no political changes, and was not even the bloodiest episode of the conflict. It is said that Verdun made France, he writes; but the question should be, What did France make of Verdun? Over time, it proved to be the last great victory of French arms, standing on their own. And, for France and Germany, the battle would symbolize the terror of industrialized warfare, "a technocratic Moloch devouring its children," where no advance or retreat was possible, yet national resources poured in ceaselessly, perpetuating slaughter indefinitely.
- Sales Rank: #750582 in Books
- Published on: 2014-02-03
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 6.40" h x 1.20" w x 9.40" l, 1.20 pounds
- Binding: Hardcover
- 336 pages
Review
"Brilliant." --Los Angeles Review of Books
"The horrors have been described often and elaborately, but Mr. Jankowski is skillful enough that his accounts still provoke." --Wall Street Journal
"One of its foremost virtues is to brush aside the insistence of modern folklore.... that Verdun imposed on its participants horrors unprecedented in history." --Max Hastings, The Sunday Times
"Jankowski recognizes the significance of the battle that Maurice Genevoix, a French novelist and World War I veteran, was said to have called 'the battle-symbol of the entire 1914-1918 war...' He relies heavily on the memoirs, journals and letters of those who were present during the battle to complete his work." --Army magazine
"Jankowski has written a superb, definitive popular account of Verdun through the eyes of soldiers, military leaders, and citizens of the two nations." --Publishers Weekly
"Jankowski's revisionist book is a major achievement...The writing throughout is of the highest order... At every stage, Jankowski integrates the military narrative with broader political and cultural dimensions... Jankowski's book offers a model history of warfare." --Philip Jenkins, Books & Culture
"Paul Jankowski's Verdun is a great book, truly a masterwork of modern literature. On a much studied event (25 percent of all the many French books on World War I have been about the battle of Verdun), he has given us a work of rare originality and creativity. And he has done it with old fashioned virtues of grace and refinement. This is not only a new interpretation of a major subject. It is also a new model of how history might be written on many subjects." --David Hackett Fischer
"This fine book straddles two generations of writing on the Great War. It is a superb account of the unfolding of the battle from the viewpoint of the commanders, and a moving narrative of the tenacity of small groups of men pushed beyond the limits of human endurance." --Jay Winter, Yale University
"Paul Jankowski provides a balanced, scholarly account of the pivotal Battle of Verdun. Within a smoothly flowing narrative, he highlights critical themes in both traditional military history and the social history of warfare. This book is a first-stop source for students of the First World War, and a superb survey of what arguably stands the greatest battle in human history." --Edward G. Lengel, author of To Conquer Hell: The Meuse-Argonne, 1918
"Paul Jankowski's Verdun is the first major study of the battle to appear in English for many years, and the first to draw fully on archival research on both sides. Jankowski presents a thoughtful, original, and moving account, full of insights into the course of the fighting and its subsequent commemoration and impact." --David Stevenson, author of Cataclysm:The First World War as Political Tragedy and With our Backs to the Wall: Victory and Defeat in 1918
About the Author
Paul Jankowski is Raymond Ginger Professor of History at Brandeis University. His many books include Stavinksy: A Confidence Man in the Republic of Virtue and Shades of Indignation: Political Scandals in France, Past and Present.
Most helpful customer reviews
22 of 22 people found the following review helpful.
Excellent analysis
By Phelps Gates
This is not a blow-by-blow description of the events at Verdun with the order of battle on each side and a detailed account of the fighting. There are other books for that, and you can get the details of what happened from the wikipedia article. What we do have here is an in-depth analysis of the meaning of Verdun, considered from several different angles. How did it fit in with Falkenhayn's overall plan for the western front? How did the French generals, especially Joffre and Pétain, react to the German attack? What were the goals of the French and the Germans? What were the conditions under which the soldiers fought and what was the state of their morale? And (perhaps most interesting) how did Verdun come to be such an iconic battle after the war, and to this day, especially for the French? Jankowski discusses these and other questions in detail and gives answers as far as can be known, without engaging in undue speculation. The book isn't perfect: the maps leave much to be desired, and the discussion of the topography is sometimes unclear. But this is an excellent book and one which will appeal both to those with a special interest in WWI and those with an interest in military history in general.
36 of 39 people found the following review helpful.
A Tale of Three Books
By Te Bada
T’s Rating System
0 to 5 with 0 the lowest score and 5 the highest and NA for not applicable:
Books (nonfiction)
Content 5
Coverage of topic 5
Adequacy of descriptions 5
Detail 5
References 5
Illustrations 3
Size 4
Detail 3
Captions 3
Sufficient Maps 3
Sufficient Drawings NA
Sufficient Photos 4
Product worth the price - Yes, 5.
There are a number of ways to analyze a battle, especially if it is the most written about engagement of World War I. There are three current books on the subject, and the approach of each is strikingly different. One is McNab’s VERDUN 1916, BATTLE STORY, smaller and more economically priced than its competition, it is rather direct in giving the reader coverage of the battle and recommended. Then there is the most popular of the new books, Mosier’s THE LOST HISTORY OF THE MOST IMPORTANT BATTLE OF WORLD WAR I: VERDUN. The author has lost sight of his claim the “most important” while going off on tangents and producing a “Gee Wiz” type of book in which he points some interesting items (some incorrect) with which the average history buff may impress his friends. Then there is Jankowski’s VERDUN: The Longest Battle of the Great War. Unlike Mosier, he does not claim the battle lasted from 1914 to 1918, but actually covered the actual battle of 1916. Both Mosier and Jankowski include a long detail bibliography, but it is clear that only the latter actually read all those books and documents. Both have a good writing style, but that does not necessarily make a good history books. Jankowski does not provide the detail of the battle found in McNab’s book (Verdun, a Battle History), but if that is what you want Alstair Horne’s book (The Price of Glory) from the 1960s still provides a decent history.
Jankowski does an excellent job in assimilating all his sources to give the reader who already knows something about the battle a better picture of the various aspects of battle including tactics, leaders, and events. The various chapters attempt to tackle such things as the French and German point of view, how the battle affected the public, moral, medical services, desertion, losses and so on. For those who have read Joffre’s and Petain’s accounts, you may have noticed something is missing. These, and other generals, as the author points out, came from the rear depending on reports, and messages, while sending out their life and death orders without actually knowing or even caring what the soldiers at the front experienced. Their front line inspections amounted to little, although Petain seemed to have a much better understanding of what was happening to his men. Meanwhile, generals like Mangin led suicidal charges from behind a desk including a desperate attempt to retake Fort Douaumont. Other officers would refuse to carry some of the directives and on the German side things were no better. The troops in Feldgrau had also become distraught by being slaughtered by French 75s and machine-guns not destroyed in the massive bombardments. Even the German Crown Prince commanding the German 5th Army questioned the leadership and strategy of his commander, General Falkenhayn. Falkenhayn only tried to explain the battle after the war when he decided to claim it was to “bleed the French white.” Unlike the other two books mentioned, this one provides some interesting evidence of how morale rose and fell on both sides, the contribution of the battle to larger mutinies the following year, and even how both sides tried to turn the results of the battle into a victory. This book is for those who already know a little about the battle of Verdun and have sufficient grey matter to want to know how this battle played out and was not a battle of attrition, but one that defined the war.
Final Rating:
Verdun by McNab - Recommend for description of the actual battle *****
Verdun by Mosier - Only recommend if your just wanting some facts to impress your friends, but not improve your understanding
of the battle. Better selection of maps than the other two books, but rather simple. Remember it includes a
number of errors and the author thinks the battle lasted 4 years. **
Verdun by Janowski - Recommend for an understanding of the various aspects of the battle and its significance. Maps not
much better than Mosier book and more needed. *****
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful.
One of the best books on the battle
By James W. Durney
For sheer murder, World War One is very high on the list with the Western Front the worst place to be.
Defensive technology was far superior to what an attacker possessed rendering trench lines almost impregnable.
The continuous line of entrenchments prevented maneuvers and there is no flank. Combatants found themselves forced into frontal assaults that do little more than kill their men. The war destroyed a generation and scared all who lived through it.
Verdun is one of the most horrific battles in history.
The French and Germans murdered each other in a sea of mud for almost a year.
During this time, they established a level of bloodshed that is unusual even for this war. “Verdun” became a code denoting unspeakable privation and death.
This book looks at Verdun in many ways.
First, this is a military history but not a detailed one. The two area maps are sufficient for the book but not for anyone trying to follow the battle closely.
Second, this is a history of how an event can take on a life of its’ own forcing the participants down paths they never intended to walk.
Third, the book is a look at how the battle was remembered by the participates and is remembered by history.
Fourth, this is a remembrance detailing the conditions during the battle. This is some of the best work I’ve read on the war. The author skillfully mixes direct quotes with observations to produce a graphic narrative of serving in the war.
While a serious history, this reads like a novel.
The book is both an introduction to the battle while being able to extend the knowledge of the experience reader.
Verdun: The Longest Battle of the Great War, by Paul Jankowski PDF
Verdun: The Longest Battle of the Great War, by Paul Jankowski EPub
Verdun: The Longest Battle of the Great War, by Paul Jankowski Doc
Verdun: The Longest Battle of the Great War, by Paul Jankowski iBooks
Verdun: The Longest Battle of the Great War, by Paul Jankowski rtf
Verdun: The Longest Battle of the Great War, by Paul Jankowski Mobipocket
Verdun: The Longest Battle of the Great War, by Paul Jankowski Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar